If you look up the words history and story in an etymological dictionary, you will find an interesting bit of trivia. Not only are the words related, they are the same word. They were not differentiatd until the 1500s. History is a story, or narrative, of events. It boasts characters as rich and intereting as anyone in fiction, settings to inspire and to revile, themes and plots which drive the story forward and a series of attempted solutions which but carry us from one chapter to the next. As Christians, we view history as God’s story of redemption. It is His story, and it is our story.
Unfortunately, many history programs treat the subject as a listing of key events, places and people. Names and dates are memorized and themes are rarely developed. Some of the better history programs place these things in context, highlighting ideas, principles and themes which reoccur across the ages. As 19th centruy historian and philosopher Thomas Carlyle commented, “The history of the world is but the biographies of great men.” A program with this or a similar approach can be quite inspiring.
Still, even this method falls short of providing children with a true mastery of the subject. History is God’s story of the nations, told through events in the lives of men. It is also a method of reasoning. Just as scientists use the scientific method to explore the natural world, historians use a variety of methods to interpret the events of the past to tell the story of the world. To practice this, children must be given the opportunity to analyze primary source documentation to reason for themselves what it was like to live in any particular age and what guiding principles historical figures lived by.
Before you imagine losing your child’s interest amongst a stack of dusty books at the university library, consider this sample lesson, A Snapshot of Victorian History. The photograph above was taken in 1887. Consider it with your child. Talk about it, ask questions and encourage him to ask questions. How are they dressed? How is their clothing different from today? Do you think they are wealthy? Why is there a cricket bat in the picture? How is the clothing differnt from today? Do you think all the children are from the same family? A photograph is like a brief glimpse into someone’s past and it can give us some clues about the time period. Alone, however, few conclusions can be drawn.

Take a look at this census return, taken in 1891. You will need to click on it for a larger image. Again, ask questions to find out as much about the family as possible. Together with the photograph, what can we know about this family? Were any of the questions answered? Look at the census return and figure out how old the children would have been in 1887. Match names to the individuals in the photograph.
In this brief lesson, you will have set your child up to approach history as a method of inquiry. As you add details, an enaging picture of Victorian life will emerge. Other documents to consider looking at are songs, poems, minutes to a meeting, court documents, a sermon, journals, letters and laws from the period. Rather than presenting the story, ask questions and present your child with documents to explore. Through your child’s inquiry, the story of history will begin to unfold.
If you enjoyed this sample lesson, this and more can be found by exploring the Learning Curves website. Thousands of primary source documents from modern history can be found at the Internet Modern History Sourcebook.
history, teaching history, homeschooling, homes school, education, Victorian
Principled Discovery is a place to stop and discuss news and information related to faith, family and particularly education. Pour yourself a cup of tea and join the conversation! 






Good post, Dana! I tend to think of using original sources as a high school thing (ie, “Go read the Federalist Papers”), but it was interesting to think about how many things could be discovered about the past by just discussing a photograph with young children. I generally take a biographical and historical fiction approach with my younger ones, but now I’ll be on the watch for an opportunity to do as you described.
Thank you, Denise! I am like you in that I tend to think of primary source documents as a high school or even college thing. I remember being told in college that it was preferable to go back to the original source where possible, but that is about it. I don’t remember ever being taught how to look at a primary source document and begin solving the mystery of what life was like, or what motivated people in their decisions. I was used to reading and regurgitating.
I think simple activities like these (which can even be entirely oral while standing in the history museum) help to show the true purposes of primary source documents and provide quite a bit of interest for students. They also provide a nice context to refer back to continually throughout a unit. Using this example, you can see the potential for drawing connections. As you study Victorian history, you can continually ask how these events and ideas might have affected the Lillywhite family, making history a little more personal.